The packaging is typical Nyx black plastic with white writing and a clear middle portion that allows you to see the color inside.
The bottom shows the innocuous name "Rose" which might lead you to expect something nice and pink and wearable. There are certainly a lot of wearable rose lip colors. This is not one of them. While it may look like one of the more wearable out of the Macaron line, this is anything but subtle. It isn't a pistachio green or a concrete grey, but it is almost more jarring as it is close to being a shade found in nature. As you can see in the context of my face, it is an alarming pastel shade of bubble gum pink.
The packaging is pretty cheap feeling, but is functional. The bullet rolls all the way down into the packaging, which is a plus so my clumsy self will avoid nicking it with the cap. The only real flaw is there is no "click" to start rolling up so I can see myself managing to squash the bullet against the inside of the cap.
Here is a swatch of it looking all lonesome on my arm. I gave this a couple of swipes to get the color opaque. Because it is so bold any patchiness becomes very obvious.
Below it is swatched in context of some other brighter pinks and purples in my collection. None are quite as white based as Rose, but the Posietint is maybe the closest in shade. Top photo is without flash, bottom is with.
Top to bottom: Pixi Shea Butter Lip Balm in Pixi Pink, Nyx Macaron Lippie in Rose, Laqa & Co Lip Lube in Menatour, Benefit Posietint, Benefit Lollitint, Benefit Lollibalm
It took me quite a few layers and a lip brush to get this applied the way I wanted but I ended up with a decently smooth result. It felt thick on the lips, very noticeable, but it did not seem to dry them out. There is a thicker deposit of product on the left side of my bottom lip that looks a little off and applying straight out of the bullet was hard to define my cupids bow.
The makeup I was wearing on the testing day was quite warm, which only assisted in making it look like my lips were floating on my face. I think if I had been wearing a more cool-tone face of make up the look would have been slightly more cohesive. That being said, this shade will never be subtle so I got some enjoyment out of playing up the white and blue in the base.
The color stayed on my lips very well for an hour of just sitting and reading. I did not eat or drink during that hour. At the end you could see that the lipstick was starting to settle a little more obviously into the cracks of my lips. This is not that surprising given how creamy the formula of this is, there is borderline too much slip for it to be trustworthy. I suspect a drier formula would not give you such a bold color. This settling also was not that obvious in the context of my whole face.
After about an hour I got thirsty and drank a glass of water, that was left with some nice lipstick prints. The transfer from this lipstick is super obvious, if not surprising given the creamy formula. It also looked a little bit worse for wear following the water, no obviously bald patches but generally more sheer toward the center of my lips.
By the two hour mark I had also eaten a handful of candied ginger and my lipstick was showing quite a bit of wear. You can see the bald patches on the left side of my mouth and that it was quite obvious even in the context of more of my face.
Overall I don't hate this lipstick, I think the look it creates is interesting. I just have found it too unusual to wear out into the world. I have worn it a few times as a cream blush, but requires an awful lot of blending and probably wouldn't work on anybody with a darker skin tone than I due to all the white in the base.
Otherwise nondescript makeup with the nyx macaron as a blush
I think this shade of lipstick would look absolutely stunning on somebody with a darker skin tone, but again it would not look any more natural. Maybe sometime this summer I will get up the courage to be one of the cool kids and wear this so other people can see.